Starting a business in Massachusetts often means owning a company with other people, a common practice for Boston startups and family-owned businesses across the state. With multiple owners, even minor disagreements can cause significant problems if there are no clear rules in place.
A shareholder agreement helps Massachusetts business owners set clear expectations and protect their working relationships. It also helps owners prepare for unexpected situations, such as a founder leaving, disputes between owners, or life events that affect the company’s control. An agreement allows shareholders to focus on running and growing the company, rather than dealing with conflict.
This article explains what a shareholder agreement is, why it matters, and how it can help business owners avoid disputes.
Please contact our attorneys by calling (617) 557-3030.
Many business owners and entrepreneurs usually wonder what a shareholder agreement is and how it differs from other corporate documents. A shareholder agreement is a private contract among a company’s shareholders that defines their rights, responsibilities, and relationship to one another. Unlike corporate bylaws, which outline how a company operates on a day-to-day basis, this agreement focuses on ownership rights and the decision-making process of shareholders.
In Massachusetts, shareholder agreements are especially important for closely held businesses. State law allows close corporations to use shareholder agreements to reallocate management authority and limit board discretion, giving owners more direct control over the company’s operations.
Business relationships often start with trust. However, trust alone is not usually enough when real-world problems arise. A clear agreement helps shareholders address common potential issues before they become disputes.
A well-drafted agreement helps address situations such as:
- Disagreements between owners. Clear voting rules and deadlock procedures reduce the risk of operational standstills.
- Life changes. Death, divorce, disability, or retirement can disrupt ownership if there is no plan in place.
- Changes in ownership. Restrictions on stock transfers help prevent unwanted third parties from becoming shareholders.
Setting rules in advance allows shareholders to maintain continuity and protect the long-term health of the business.
How Do These Agreements Control Decision-Making?
Decision-making is often the source of the most serious disputes among shareholders. Shareholder agreements help prevent these conflicts by outlining who has authority to make decisions and how votes are counted.
Common decision-making provisions include:
- Voting thresholds. Certain actions may require unanimous consent or a supermajority vote.
- Deadlock resolution. The agreement can outline mediation, buyouts, or other solutions if owners reach an impasse.
- Director and officer selection. Shareholders can agree on how leaders are appointed or removed.
These provisions help keep the company moving forward even when shareholders disagree.
Ownership changes are inevitable over the life of a business. A shareholder transfer agreement provision controls how and when shares may be sold or transferred.
A strong transfer framework protects the company by addressing:
- Right of first refusal—existing shareholders get the option to buy shares before they are sold to outsiders;
- Tag-along rights—minority shareholders can participate if a majority owner sells their shares; and
- Drag-along rights—minority shareholders may have to sell if a majority approves a sale.
These rules help preserve stability and prevent ownership disputes that can damage the business.
Although limited liability companies (LLCs) do not technically have shareholders, many business owners still search for an LLC shareholder agreement. In practice, LLCs use operating agreements to serve a similar purpose.
An operating agreement addresses member rights, profit distribution, management authority, and exit strategies. For businesses choosing between a corporation and an LLC, understanding how these documents work together is essential to structuring the company correctly.
Startup companies often delay formal agreements because of everyone’s focus on growth. A startup shareholder agreement helps prevent minor issues from escalating into major problems as the company grows.
For startups, these agreements often address:
- Founder roles and responsibilities,
- Equity ownership and vesting schedules, and
- Founder departures and their impact on ownership and control.
Putting these terms in writing early provides clarity for founders. It also reassures investors that the business has a solid legal foundation.
A shareholder agreement is most effective when it aligns with other governance documents. Depending on the business structure, this may include articles of organization, corporate bylaws, or operating agreements.
When these documents conflict, disputes are more likely to arise. Coordinating them carefully helps reduce risk and supports smoother operations over time.
Drafting a shareholder agreement requires more than filling in a template. It involves understanding Massachusetts law, anticipating potential future disputes, and striking a balance between legal protection and practical business goals. Choosing the right legal team helps you build a governance structure that supports stability, growth, and long-term success.
Berluti McLaughlin & Kutchin, LLP, brings decades of experience advising closely held businesses, startups, and established companies throughout Massachusetts. Our attorneys regularly handle complex shareholder disputes and transactional matters. This experience gives us insight into how agreements hold up when challenged. We work closely with business owners to identify risks and address ownership concerns. Our team can then create agreements that reflect how the company actually operates.
Contact our office today to learn how we can help review or draft your company’s shareholders’ agreement and other critical documents. Let us help your business grow.
Practicing Attorneys
Frequently Asked Questions
You can draft your own agreement, but doing so carries risk. Shareholder agreements must comply with Massachusetts law and align with other corporate documents. Ambiguous or incomplete terms often lead to disputes that cost more to resolve than proper drafting.
Yes. A properly drafted and signed shareholder agreement is legally binding under Massachusetts law. Courts generally enforce these agreements if they meet statutory requirements and do not violate public policy.
The cost varies depending on the company’s size, complexity, and ownership structure. Businesses with multiple owners, investors, or unique transfer rules typically require more detailed agreements. A BMK attorney can provide guidance after reviewing your specific needs.
You May Also Like
BMK attorneys Robert Berluti and Brendan Cooke represented a tax firm in a dispute with a former client who refused to pay the agreed-upon contingent fee for a whistleblower...
Read more
Reaching an executive role often feels like the finish line. However, the paperwork that comes with it can shape your future just as much as the job itself. The...
Read more
Most people know that having a will is crucial to ensure your assets end up where you want them to go after you die. However, common misconceptions abound about...
Read more